Alternative music in XMAS99 DLC

There are two NiGHTS-related music tracks on Sonic Adventure GD-ROM. One is called NIGHTS_A, which is the a capella cover of “Dreams Dreams”. The other is called NIGHTS_S, which is another mix of “Dreams Dreams” called “Sweet Mix in the Holy Night”. The A version is the one you hear with the Christmas 99 DLC when you touch any of the Christmas trees, the other one you don’t get to hear ingame normally but there’s a bit more to it than the song being unused.

A while back I found out that the S version is actually referenced in the Christmas 99 DLC, but the object that plays the song never loads because it has the “wrong” level ID, and the one that plays the A version gets loaded in its place because it has the “right” level ID. In the game’s internal level list Station Square has the ID of 26, while the objects playing the S version use 27 and 28. It’s pretty clear that at some point in development the game had the day, evening and night versions of Station Square use different internal IDs, even though the final game only uses 26. Even the “Easy Menu” in SADX Preview prototype refers to 27 and 28 as evening and night versions respectively.

The XMAS99 DLC places four Christmas trees around Station Square. If you look at its object placement (which you can do with the DLC Tool in SA Tools), you can see that for each of those trees there are “evening” and “night” versions that are supposed to load in levels 27 and 28. One of the parameters in those objects is the music track ID to play. The regular “day” trees use 68, which corresponds to NIGHTS_A, but some of the “evening” and “night” trees use 70, which is NIGHTS_S. For example, this one in the City Hall area:

While it is trivial to switch the IDs around and make these trees play the S version at all times, I don’t know of a way to restore the seemingly intended functionality with the trees playing different songs at different times of day. The old Dreamcast DLCs mod for SADX had this behavior hardcoded, but the new mod loads objects in a way a bit more similar to the Dreamcast version, so it doesn’t work for the same reason it doesn’t work in the original. I’ll probably just make this tree play the S version because why not?

There’s one more interesting thing about this DLC and unused NiGHTS songs in SA1. We’ve seen both music IDs 68 and 70 used, but what about 69? While it isn’t referenced in the DLC, we know from the PC version that there was supposed to be yet another NiGHTS song called NIGHTS_K, which would be using this ID. As no version of the game has this file, we can’t say for sure what was supposed to be. The Kids version of “Dreams, Dreams”? The Karaoke version? “Know Thyself!” maybe? To me, the Karaoke version makes the most sense, but we can only guess.

The updated DLCs mod for SADX PC is coming along well. I rewrote the entire mod from scratch and made it work in a way that resembles the functionality used in the original game. It’s also partially compatible with original data from SA1 DLC files provided that you convert it first using the DLC tool and replace some of the stuff that isn’t supported by the PC version, such as MLT soundbanks. Model and metadata files are fully compatible. So in the future if you decide to make a custom DLC for the Dreamcast version, you will be able to prototype it in SADX PC first using the new DLC mod, which makes object placement easier.

Just… why

I’ve been wondering for a long time how SA1 draws its “Now Saving” and DLC timer strings. Apart from being italicized (and looking glitchy with letters overlapping each other) the font looks thicker than the font used in debug menus, and the 0 character looks different, and I started thinking it was a different font altogether.

Today Exant figured it out, and the answer to all this is just… Weird. It’s the same font, but there’s code that… replaces the zeroes in text with the letter O. The rest is a lot more believable: the font looks thicker because the letters are stretched horizontally, and the italics are done by offsetting the top right X coordinate of the letter’s rectangle.

I’ll be updating DC Conversion and the DLCs mod to improve the look of the font, though I also want to rework the DLCs mod from the ground up. I want to make it possible to load the data produced by the SA1 DLC tool I made for SA Tools. That way you’ll be able to convert DLCs between SA1 and SADX. There’s some fundamental incompatibility with sounds and music, which I won’t be able to resolve in a while, so it will probably be only partially compatible, but anyway I’ll save that for another post.

You can now make your own SA1 Dreamcast DLC

I’ve added my DLC tool to the SA Tools suite, you can find it in the SA1 folder. It’s a simple command line tool that unpacks VMS files and rebuilds them from source assets and metadata. I want to make a GUI version of it someday, but for now I want to work on something else. The tool and the data should be self explanatory for the most part, and there’s also plenty of documentation in the readme file.

For those who want some juicy details, here’s the layout of SA1 DLC files:

 * 0		16		string		DLC title
 * 10		32		string		DLC description
 * 30		16		string		Application title
 * 40		2		ushort		Number of icons
 * 42		2		ushort		Animation speed
 * 44		2		ushort		Eyecatch type (unused)
 * 46		2		ushort		CRC (unused)
 * 48		4		uint32		Size without the header
 * 4C		20		null		Reserved
 * 60		32		ushort		Icon palette, 16 colors
 * 80		512		byte		Icon graphics
 * 280		4		uint32		Pointer to item layout table
 * 284		4		uint32		Item count
 * 288		4		uint32		Pointer to string table
 * 28C		4		uint32		String item count
 * 290		4		uint32		Pointer to PVM
 * 294		4		uint32		Number of PVMs (always 1)
 * 298		4		uint32		Number of textures in the PVM
 * 29C		4		uint32		Pointer to MLT
 * 2A0		4		uint32		Number of MLTs (either 0 or 1)
 * 2A4		4		uint32		Pointer to PRS
 * 2A8		4		uint32		Number of PRSes (always 1)
 * 2AC		4		uint32		Checksum
 * 2B0		16		null		Unused
 * 2C0		4		uint32		DLC ID (e.g. 504 in SONICADV_504)
 * 2C4		1		byte		Enable Sonic / Enable Tails
 * 2C5		1		byte		Enable Knuckles / Enable Gamma
 * 2C6		1		byte		Enable Amy / Enable Big
 * 2C7		1		byte		Unknown, probably unused
 * 2C8		4		uint32		Regional lock
 *  0		1		uint8		Level ID
 *  1		1		uint8		Act ID
 *  2		1		uint8		Scale X multiplied by 10
 *  3		1		uint8		Scale Y multiplied by 10
 *  4		1		uint8		Scale Z multiplied by 10
 *  5		1		uint8		Rotation speed X
 *  6		1		uint8		Rotation speed Y
 *  7		1		uint8		Rotation speed Z
 *  8		1		sint8		Item type (0: model, -128: sprite, -1: invisible)
 *  9		1		uint8		Texture ID
 *  A		2		ushort		Flags
 *  C		1		uint8		Object ID for collectibles or the number of objects to collect
 *  D		1		byte		Unknown
 *  E		1		uint8		Message ID to show when touching the object
 *  F		1		uint8		Trigger distance
 *  10		1		uint8		Level ID to warp or soundbank ID (8 for MLT, 15 for ADX music)
 *  11		1		uint8		Act ID to warp to or sound/music ID to play
 *  12		2		ushort		Rotation X
 *  14		2		ushort		Rotation Y
 *  16		2		ushort		Rotation Z
 *  18		2		short		Position X
 *  1A		2		short		Position Y
 *  1C		2		short		Position Z
 *  BIT_0	Unknown
 *  BIT_4	Unknown
 *  BIT_8	Solid
 *  BIT_9	Play sound
 *  BIT_10	Show message
 *  BIT_11	Hide object and disable everything except collision
 *  BIT_12	Warp
 *  BIT_13	Collectible item
 *  BIT_14	Timer item
 *  BIT_15	Starts the challenge
 *  -1	Disable regional lock
 *   1	Japan
 *   3	US
 *   4	Europe
 *   7	All regions

Sonic Adventure: “Tikal’s challenge” DLC contest!

This release is for the original Dreamcast game, not SADX PC. A PC version of the challenge will be available at a later date.

Today I’m releasing something a bit special. This is the first fully custom* Dreamcast Sonic Adventure DLC that adds a new challenge without hacking the base game. It’s built like the official SA1 DLCs, and it makes use of SA1’s internal system to add objects and challenges to the game.

Download for emulators or transfer from PC
VMI file download for Dreamcast browser

To stay true to the spirit of official SA1 DLCs I’d like to make this a contest with a “real” (though merely symbolic) prize. To participate, simply record your playthrough of this challenge and share the video. You can play it on an emulator or on a real Dreamcast. The fastest player who beats the challenge in the shortest amount of time will get a free Sonic Adventure DX Steam key from me.

The contest will run until September 23rd, 0:00 (UTC). The deadline may be extended depending on the number of entries.
Submit your results here

To get started, you need to import the file SONICADV_515.VMS or SONICADV_515.DCI to your memory card. On PC you can use a memory card editor (such as redream’s save manager). To play it on hardware you could burn the file to a CD together with Dream Explorer, or use an SD card adapter with DreamShell. If your Dreamcast is connected to the Internet, you can download it from the revived official webpage directly from Sonic Adventure!

This DLC was made using a tool that I’ve been developing during the last several days. Once the tool is released you will be able to make your own DLCs for Sonic Adventure from scratch (within the limits of the game’s DLC system of course)!

*Technically it’s not the first edit of a DLC, but it is the first DLC that adds custom objectives and makes extensive use of the DLC system rather than edits object properties. Huge thanks to Sappharad for figuring out the integrity check for the DLCs, which made this whole thing possible.

-Darksecond for figuring out SA1 DLC and rank data encryption and posting it on ASSEMbler
-Sappharad for providing C# code to decrypt SA1 DLCs and for cracking the integrity check
-Daguar for giving me a hint on where to look for DLC item table
-Exant for making a lightweight “sitting Chao” model
-The graphics are based on Sonic Adventure (+DX) assets


Weird text in Sonic Adventure DLCs

I’m working on a tool to extract SA1 Dreamcast DLC files. While we’ve already gotten most of their data extracted and the content is recreated in the Dreamcast DLCs mod for SADX, I want to make a tool to work with DLC files directly and get everything out – item layout, text data, textures etc. I also want to make it possible to modify and rebuild DLC files.

Now why this is included after some text strings, I’m not sure. Some DLCs just have stuff inserted that makes little sense. Random garbage from memory? Some kind of weird anti-tamper measure? Who knows. Maybe I’ll figure it out eventually.

Unreferenced Chao flowers

I found this unreferenced flowers model in leaked SADX X360 symbols. It uses the Dreamcast version’s CHAO.PVM and is located in the same region as objects used in the Chao Race on DC, such as the watering can or the trumpet. What is it? Some kind of unused Chao Race object or toy? No idea.

If you want to have a look at this model, you can find it in AL_MAIN.BIN (SA1 v1.005) at 14E10C.

NB file woes

This post documents my experience with Sonic Adventure NB files and my attempts to reverse engineer the format.

NB is some kind of container format for models and animations. It’s different from container formats used in the Katana SDK, and I haven’t seen any other games use it. There are only two NB files in Sonic Adventure/DX that are used in all versions of the game: E101R.NB and EROBO.NB. As you may guess from their names, they contain models and animations for ZERO and E-101R MK II boss fights. A lot of stuff in these NB files can be found elsewhere in the game – for example, Zero’s model and animations also exist in the main binary in the 2004 version of SADX, and E101R has a cutscene model that can be ripped easily. But NB files also contain miscellaneous models for things used in these fights, such as explosions, projectiles and electric barriers, as well as some unique boss animations.

On the Gamecube the NB files are byteswapped and called E101R_GC.NB and EROBO_GC.NB, but in the PC version they are Little Endian despite the “_GC” in the filenames. Apart from Endianness the format itself is the same between all versions, and files from the Dreamcast version will work with the PC version if you simply rename them.

The NB file is composed of binary sections preceded by an 8-byte header. A section can contain models, motions or shape motions (the NB files in SA1/SADX do not contain shape motions, but I found some shape motion loading code associated with one of the section types). Each section is divided into subsections, which have their own headers and contain various types of data. For models it’s vertices, normals, materials, meshsets, UVs, model and object structures. For animations it’s rotations, positions, motion data structures and finally the motion structure itself.

So first I wanted to extract models and animations from NB files. I started with the program called SplitNB in SA Tools, which was already capable of splitting out individual binary sections from the NB file. Getting the models out of those sections was easy because the root model is always at the end of the file, so just loading a model at its address got the whole model hierarchy covered. Animations were a lot more involved, since the motion at the end of the file wouldn’t load without modifications. After a few attempts I managed to reconstruct the full animation from those individual subsections, and you can now use SplitNB in SA Tools to extract both models and animations from NB files.

The next logical step was to try and recreate those NB files from actual models and animations. That was pretty complicated since I couldn’t just write out the whole model – I needed to break all its data into sections. Same with animations, which had to have rotations and positions stored in separate sections with correct pointers to them in the motion data section.

So I managed to rebuild NB files from models and animations extracted from them previously. ZERO worked right away, but with E101R the game froze while still playing the music. After comparing original and recreated sections I found the culprit – one of the motion sections didn’t match. The original motion’s rotations section contained two rotation keyframes that my code wasn’t picking up, and the resulting section was 32 bytes smaller. But when I looked at those rotations I found out why they weren’t being picked up – they weren’t referenced anywhere in the file. Unused/leftover animation data? I don’t know, but because it’s unused, the program doesn’t include it in the extracted animation, so the rebuilt section doesn’t have it either.

But even then, why would the game freeze if the data included in the file is correct and all pointers are valid? I open the disassembly and I see this shit:

So yes, despite being able to load a pretty elaborate container format, the game uses hardcoded offsets for models in NB files, which makes any NB file rebuilding useless without additional modification of the game’s code.

Can this be worked around? Sure, if you change the offsets in code to match those in your NB file it might work. Also it will certainly work if you rebuild the file in a way that keeps original offsets for models, though it limits the possible scope of modification quite a lot. It’s disappointing because I wanted to make SA Tools support splitting and building these files for easy modification, but this hardcoded stuff is too much effort to change such specific parts of the game. I’m still going to update SA Tools with a tool to rebuild these files for lighter edits, so at least we can have that. Oh, and if you just wanted the models or animations for use in other projects, you can already have them.

This concludes my investigation into SA1/DX NB files. If you’re interested in the specifics of the format, SplitNB source code has some documentation.